Are antibiotics used to treat Lyme disease effective?

Woman taking antibiotic pills

As the number of individuals contracting Lyme disease grows, along with an ever increasing number of patients suffering from chronic symptoms, the question often arises as to whether antibiotics used to treat Lyme disease are actually effective?

An article entitled “Antibiotic treatment in patients that present with solely non-specific symptoms and positive serology at a Lyme centre,” published in the European Journal of Internal Medicine, ¹ describes a study which addresses the question: Are short-term antibiotics used to treat Lyme disease effective in patients whose symptoms are subjective?

The study examined 97 patients who presented with non-specific symptoms and had no previous treatment for Lyme disease but were positive by immunoglobulin G (IgG) serology tests.

“Non-specific” symptoms included:

  • Myalgia/arthralgia
  • Fatigue (includes lethargy and loss of energy)
  • Sleep disturbances
  • Headache
  • Inflammatory symptoms (includes fever, temperature rise, sore throat, and night sweats)
  • Cognitive disorder
  • Sensory disorder
  • Digestive disorder
  • Dizziness/lightheadedness
  • Shortness of breath/palpitations
  • Mood disorder

Researchers looked at whether these patients would benefit from antibiotics used to treat Lyme disease and whether certain patient characteristics contributed to treatment success.

Study results

They found that nearly 50% of patients “had a clear or intermediate effect from antibiotic treatment.”

Most of the 97 patients were adults. Over 70% were men. And, the non-specific symptoms had been present for an average of 2 years.

Doxycycline was one of the antibiotics used to treat Lyme disease. The remaining patients received amoxicillin. A 4-week course was prescribed to most of the patients. Interestingly, patients with inflammatory symptoms benefited the most from doxycycline.

Does a short course of antibiotics help Lyme disease patients who have non-specific symptoms, like fatigue, mood disturbances and sleep disturbances? Click To Tweet

Furthermore, “patients with symptoms suggestive for inflammatory disease and patients with the IgG immunoblot antigen p58 benefited significantly more often from antibiotic treatment compared to patients without these characteristics,” the authors point out.

Of the 97 patients who improved with antibiotics, 15.5% had a clear effect from antibiotic treatment, while 26.8% had an intermediate effect and 50.5% experienced no effect.

Authors conclude

“This study shows that antibiotics possibly have an effect on non-specific symptoms in previously untreated patients with positive Borrelia serology,” the authors conclude.

“However, these beneficial effects were intermediate in a considerable amount of patients.”

The authors suggest, an RCT [randomized clinical trial] “is needed to validate our findings, relevant for clinicians in Lyme centres.”

They also point out that an improvement of symptoms may have been the result of eradicating another pathogen and not Borrelia burgdorferi, the causative agent of Lyme disease.

“Symptoms suggestive for inflammatory disease were associated with treatment effect. This could indicate an effect of antibiotic treatment on pathogens related to diseases other than LB [Lyme borreliosis].”

Studies dispute antibiotic benefits

Meanwhile, findings from the Klempner clinical trial, sponsored by the National Institutes of Health (NIH), suggest that antibiotics used to treat Lyme disease would not be beneficial to patients with non-specific symptoms.²

However, that trial enrolled patients who had been ill an average of 4.7 years and who had already failed an average of 2 treatments.

Another trial, also sponsored by the NIH, found that antibiotics would be helpful but only for Lyme disease patients suffering from fatigue and not for other non-specific symptoms.³

 

Editor’s Note:

The study featured in the European Journal of Internal Medicine has several limitations. Treatment effectiveness may have been due to a pathogen other than Lyme disease. And there was no controlled study population.

That said, the results should encourage additional research on the benefits of antibiotics used to treat Lyme disease patients who suffer from non-specific symptoms.

 

References:
  1. Nijman G, van Kooten B, Vermeeren YM, van Hees BC4, Zomer TP. Antibiotic treatment in patients that present with solely non-specific symptoms and positive serology at a Lyme centre. Eur J Intern Med. 2020 Feb 15.
  2. Klempner MS, Hu LT, Evans J, Schmid CH, Johnson GM, Trevino RP, et al. Two
    controlled trials of antibiotic treatment in patients with persistent symptoms and a
    history of lyme disease. N Engl J Med 2001;345:85–92. https://doi.org/10.1056/
    NEJM200107123450202.
  3. Krupp LB, Hyman LG, Grimson R, Coyle PK, Melville P, Ahnn S, et al. Study and
    treatment of post lyme disease (STOP-LD): a randomized double masked clinical
    trial. Neurology.
Latest From the Lyme Disease Science Blog


8 Replies to "Are antibiotics used to treat Lyme disease effective?"

  • Wendy
    05/21/2020 (8:16 pm)
    Reply

    Are there any other treatments besides Doxy? I just cannot take that

    • Dr. Daniel Cameron
      05/22/2020 (4:08 pm)
      Reply

      There are a range of other antibiotic treatments to consider that are easier to tolerate i.e., amoxicillin, Ceftin, Zithromax, Biaxin, Malarone depending on your situation.

  • Loretha F Allen
    03/08/2020 (6:08 am)
    Reply

    I have had Lymes since August, 2016. I have had one treatment session of medicine through an IV line because I had a pick line in my arm for 28 days. I am still sick with nausea, inflammation, headaches and all the symptoms of lymes. I feel really bad. I have been taking antiobiotics off and on for that period of time. I am still sick. I would like to know what your suggestions are on what you think I should do.

    • Dr. Daniel Cameron
      03/08/2020 (8:18 am)
      Reply

      I cannot make specific suggestions without seeing you.

  • Dasha Trebichavska
    03/07/2020 (10:54 pm)
    Reply

    I wonder how Lyme can turn into autoimmune presentation and how it can muddy the whole picture? One can have both chronic infections and autoimmune condition (as a result of these infections); the result is lots of inflammation and when using antibiotics–even more inflammation; can one stay on low doses of antibiotics for a long period of time, rotate and use anti-inflammatory medicine with steroids? I believe many of us have incompetent immune system–not enough fighter wbc-lymphocytes and not enough suppressive wbc–to control the inflammation…

    • Dr. Daniel Cameron
      03/08/2020 (8:17 am)
      Reply

      I still find antibiotics important in my practice. I sometimes find a treatment that has been overlooked. We don’t have very many other options for the immune system. I typically advise consultations with specialists to rule out other illnesses.

  • Christina
    03/07/2020 (7:05 am)
    Reply

    I had Lyme disease 15 years ago & was treated with doxycycline for 10 days. For the last 5 years I have had inconsistent joint aching, tiredness, irritability, dizziness etc. I recently had about 25 blood tests to determine cause of my problem including a test for Lyme (of course it was negative). All tests were negative.
    I believe that I may still have Lyme. The doctor put me on hydroxychloroquine (1/2 of 200 mg) & meloxicam. After 6 weeks I had a allergic reaction to hydrox though it was helping joint issues. I take meloxicam as needed which also helps. There is no diagnosis & doctor does not believe I still may have Lyme.
    What further testing can be done? I do not think doctors in Florida are knowledgeable about Lyme disease.

    • Dr. Daniel Cameron
      03/07/2020 (8:14 am)
      Reply

      I advise my patients that there is at least 20% of individuals with Lyme disease who are treated for 10 days are sick on long term followup. I advise my patients that they should see a doctor using clinical judgment if the tests are negative.


Join the Lyme Conversation
(Note: comments are moderated. You will see your comment after it has been reviewed.)

Some html is OK