Single dose prophylactic treatment of a tick bite only prevents a Lyme rash

In a recent review entitled “Lyme Disease: Emergency Department Considerations,” the authors recommend using a one-time, single dose of doxycycline for the prophylactic treatment of a tick bite, [1] despite the fact that there has been only one study exploring the effectiveness of such a limited dosage. The article also neglects to mention that there are doctors who take a different approach and advise against a one-time, single dose. [2]

 

by Daniel J. Cameron, MD MPH

The authors cite the 2006 Infectious Diseases Society of America (IDSA) guidelines when making their recommendation that “individuals be treated with a single dose of doxycycline (4 mg/kg in children ≥8 years of age to a maximum 200 mg and 200 mg in adults)”. [1] Their recommendation applies only to patients meeting the following criteria, “(1) the attached tick is clearly identified as a nymph or adult I. scapularis; (2) the tick has been attached ≥36 hours; (3) local infection rates of ticks with B. burgdorferi is ≥20%; and (4) there are no contraindications to doxycycline.” [3]

The IDSA guidelines adopted the single, 200 mg dose of doxycycline despite the fact that three previous prophylactic antibiotic trials for a tick bite had failed.

The authors fail to mention that the IDSA single dose of doxycycline approach is based on a single study, which only found a reduction in the number of erythema migrans (EM) rashes. “A study by Nadelman et al. found that patients treated with a single dose of doxycycline developed EM manifestation at a lower rate than the placebo group (0.4% compared to 3.2%, respectively),” according to Applegren from the School of Medicine, University of Missouri.

The review also does not mention the evidence, as put forth by the International Lyme and Associated Diseases Society (ILADS), which finds that a single dose is ineffective in warding off Lyme disease. Such evidence was easily accessible via open access, peer-reviewed journals in PubMed [2], the Journal’s website, [4] and the National Guideline Clearing House. [5]

ILADS 2014 guidelines used the Grading of Recommendations Assessment, Development and Evaluation (GRADE) system to conclude that the evidence for a single, 200 mg dose of doxycycline was “sparse, coming from a single study with few events, and, thus, imprecise.” [2]

There were only 9 EM rashes in the Nadelman study. Nadelman and colleagues were able to reduce the number of rashes from eight to one by prescribing a single 200 mg dose of doxycycline. The “p” value was barely significant at 0.04.

The IDSA guidelines adopted the single, 200 mg dose of doxycycline despite the fact that three previous prophylactic antibiotic trials for a tick bite had failed.

Nadelman’s study had several other limitations:

  1. It was not designed to detect Lyme disease if the rash were absent.
  2. The 6-week observation period was not designed to detect chronic or late manifestations of Lyme disease.
  3. It was not designed to assess whether a single dose of doxycycline might be effective for preventing other tick-borne illnesses such as Ehrlichia, Anaplasmosis, or Borrelia miyamotoi.

Today, patients expect to be informed of their treatment options. The recent review in the Journal of Emergency Medicine [1] would have been stronger if the authors had disclosed the evidence against using a single, 200 mg dose of doxycycline for prophylactic treatment of a tick bite.

 

References:

  1. Applegren ND, Kraus CK. Lyme Disease: Emergency Department Considerations. J Emerg Med, (2017).
  2. Cameron DJ, Johnson LB, Maloney EL. Evidence assessments and guideline recommendations in Lyme disease: the clinical management of known tick bites, erythema migrans rashes and persistent disease. Expert Rev Anti Infect Ther, 1-33 (2014).
  3. Wormser GP, Dattwyler RJ, Shapiro ED et al. The clinical assessment, treatment, and prevention of lyme disease, human granulocytic anaplasmosis, and babesiosis: clinical practice guidelines by the Infectious Diseases Society of America. Clin Infect Dis, 43(9), 1089-1134 (2006).
  4. Cameron DJ, Johnson LB, Maloney EL. Evidence assessments and guideline recommendations in Lyme disease: the clinical management of known tick bites, erythema migrans rashes and persistent disease from Expert Review of Anti-infective Therapy 2014 at https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1586/14787210.2014.940900. (Last accessed 1/3/16).
  5. Evidence assessments and guideline recommendations in Lyme disease: the clinical management of known tick bites, erythema migrans rashes and persistent disease. National Guideline Clearinghouse. Agency for Health Care Research and Quality. Available from: https://www.guideline.gov/content.aspx?id=49320. (Last accessed 10/11/15).


22
Be Part Of The Conversation

avatar
12 Comment threads
10 Thread replies
0 Followers
 
Most reacted comment
Hottest comment thread
16 Comment authors
mDr. Daniel CameronRebecca CapmanTony MichaelsJ Hemingway Recent comment authors
  Subscribe  
newest oldest most voted
Notify of
m
Guest
m

wow I’m glad I found this website, aren’t you wonderful for answering everyone’s questions! I literally “felt” a bite on my leg yesterday, pulled up my pants and saw the tiniest black dot imaginable. The tick was easy to remove, totally see through belly and I don’t believe it was on me very long BUT that is only based on my feeling of the bite and the fact it isn’t engorged. I live on the island of Nantucket. New here, and everyone is screaming at me to take 2 Doxycycline immediately. Thing is, I am currently trying to get pregnant… Read more »

Rebecca Capman
Guest
Rebecca Capman

I was bitten yesterday by a female deer tick. I don’t think it was attached for more than 12 hours. I have a small red welt but it has faded significantly after about 14 hours. I have multiple sclerosis and a compromised immune system. I’ve notified my primary doctor and am waiting for her recommendation. What are your thoughts on my predicament?
Thank you.

Tony Michaels
Guest
Tony Michaels

Tony Michaels Hi there – I found what I believe to be a male Lone Star tick on my waist this past Saturday afternoon. I am basing that assumption that it was a male Lone Star tick on photographic comparisons I have made between the tick I removed and various photos I have viewed on-line. I am not certain if the tick attached itself this past Friday afternoon while on a golf course or while I was in my backyard Saturday morning/afternoon. Based on the timeline, I believe the maximum time it could have been attached was 30 hours while… Read more »

J Hemingway
Guest
J Hemingway

Hi Dr. Cameron, former nurse with a deer tick bite yesterday. Unfortunately, I did not recognize it as a tick and it was there at least 3-4 days and was engorged when I removed. I am in NC. Frustrating afternoon of going to urgent care and making multiple calls to practitioners and pharmacists who could not offer or offered conflicting advice. The young PA (from NJ) at urgent care subscribes to the single dose doxy. Thankfully, while frantically researching in the waiting room, I came across the ILADS site. I showed it to the PA and asked to call (to… Read more »

Dan
Guest
Dan

I noticed a bullseye shaped bruise on my leg at the end of April but never noticed anything on me or felt a bite. The mark was about an inch across. I went to a doctor and they gave me the single dose of doxycycline incase it was a tick bite. The mark never grew and faded like any normal bruise. I never had any symptoms of lyme and still dont it has been 3 weeks now. Is there a chance the mark was not tick or lyme related? It kind of felt like a bruise when touched. It had… Read more »

Janice
Guest
Janice

Today I removed an embedded female nymph deer tick which was on me 12-20 hours I think I took it to the local health department and the tester said it did not look engorged – I will have the test results in 3 days. In early 1990’s I had severe late stage Lyme with Neurological , arthritic and cardiac symptoms and ended up doing over 3 months of rocephin. Because of the previous severe problem,should I start antibiotics now? Wait 3 days? If the health department says it is not engorged is that a very Definitive diagnosis? They tests for… Read more »

Ben Wildes
Guest
Ben Wildes

I was given a single dose doxycycline treatment for tick bite at a walk-in clinic. Weeks later I went back because I felt like I had symptoms of Lyme. The doctor there said that they don’t do follow-up for lyme, and that I would have to find someone else. I was sick everyday for a few more weeks until I could convince another doctor to give me 20 days of doxycycline. I finally got better and I’m okay now. Do not trust the single-dose treatment.

jz
Guest
jz

Hi – If a prophylactic antibiotic is not the right course of action, what is a better approach?

Marta O’Bosky
Guest
Marta O’Bosky

I had also received 1 time dose to prevent Lyme. 2 months later came down with all the Lyme symptoms and 6 years later am still chronically ill with Lyme, Bartonella and Babesia. Years of antibiotics, herbs, supplements have done nothing. I’m in constant full body pain… they always talk about treating Lyme right away, but what about coinfections? So many people are not just infected with Lyme but also multitude of other infections. There needs to be early treatments that can treat them all.

Conrad Miller
Guest
Conrad Miller

The truth is that as soon as the tick injects its evil brew of germs and toxins into the bitten-person’s body, these are there and the organisms will multiply vs. the individual’s immune system. Rash or no rash the borrelia, erlichia, babesiosis et al organisms will be using one’s body as a medium, symbiotic or parasitic, with there no likely 48 hour time clock threshold existing for all potential Lyme Disease victims to begin being ‘diseased’ as once proclaimed by Stony Brook Lyme Physician Dattwyler..

Jennifer
Guest
Jennifer

I have asked this before and I ask it again….Is there proof that the tick has to be attached for 24 hours in order for the virus to pass from the host? I would like to check this study out. I can’t seem to find anything only that “that’s just how we roll attitude”. How do they know this? What were the tests done on? When did this take place? How many times was this proven in the testing? Where’s the proof?!

Joyce Dahlberg
Guest
Joyce Dahlberg

The # of hours is just an opinion. There has been no research done on this. It is only assuming. If you read articles many have different length. It is beyond a pandemic. It is not being acknowledged to reduce fear only. In my opinion hell will break loose very soon. Just a few days ago a 8 year old died 10 days after going to the doctors and was given another diagnosis. She died from a co infection of lyme that can be transmitted as fast as within 15 minutes. Only by drastic measures will something be done. THE… Read more »

Lorna
Guest
Lorna

I have had Lyme – the bullseye rash, etc. – with a tick attached for less than 24 hours.

Jeff Levy
Guest

Here is a brief video that answers this question: https://youtu.be/296pVc5Zbxw

Tricia
Guest

This is exactly how my daughter at 7 became chronically ill with Lyme disease and suffered for 6 years while being bedridden. Her pediatrician assured me that a single prophylactic course of Doxy would completely prevent Lyme. Her ignorance caused my daughter to lose years of her childhood/teen years.